Medical Discovery NewsBridging the World of Medical Discovery and You

Recent Episodes

A Spoonful of Placebo

MP3 WAV

  • I'm not feeling well. I'm heading home to take a "placebo"!

    Okay Einstein, I have no clue what you're talking about; but I'm curious.

    I was surprised to find half of doctors in a recent survey admitted to prescribing placebos to their patients. They do it because, in studies, patients report feeling better.

    Yeah... I remember my Aunt Sofie insisted her doctor prescribe a "pill" for all her maladies. I never told her that some were just vitamins, yet she was convinced they did the job!

    These pills can be sugar pills, or over the counter medications ' the key being that they have no impact on the disease. Yet in many cases, patients report their symptoms improve!

    That's good for them, but they may not realize their doctors face a dilemma every time they prescribe a placebo. That's because it's considered unethical for them to do so without telling the patient.

    This is considered informed consent.

    The dilemma exists because ' as you're probably thinking ' if patients knew they were taking placebos the effect would be lost. But now a new study suggests that may not be true.

    In the study, patients suffering from Irritable Bowel Syndrome or IBS were told they were receiving an inactive placebo. Even the pill bottle was labeled ' "Placebo." However, in many cases, these patients reported positive effects.

    At the end of three weeks, patients were surveyed, and there was a significant positive difference between those receiving the placebo and those receiving nothing at all.

    Some are critical of the study, suggesting that open-minded people took part in the study and "wanted" a positive effect therefore clouding the results.

    Yet the findings remain interesting and may pave the way for informed use of placebos for chronic diseases. The report also adds to the on-going discussion that psychological treatments may lead to physiological benefits.

More Information

Placebos without deception: a randomized controlled trial in irritable bowel syndrome
Kaptchuk TJ, Friedlander E, Kelley JM, et al. Original journal article by a biomedical research group who have extensively studied the effect of placebos. PLoS One. 2010;5(12):1'7.

Benefits of a Placebo in Adults With IBS Do Not Depend on Deception, Study Shows
On line article from the NIH National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine which describes the placebo study and the mind-body healing that occurred in this well controlled study.
For more information...

Placebo Effect: A Cure in the Mind
Scientific American Article (Maj-Britt Niemi) that provides a nice overview of the area. ' "Belief is powerful medicine, even if the treatment itself is a sham. New research shows placebos can also benefit patients who do not have faith in them."
For more information...

Two individuals wearing headphones stand in a recording booth, speaking into microphones with a music stand holding printed pages between them.

 Medicine...

Medicine is constantly advancing – that is a great thing about life in the 21st century. But it doesn’t just happen. Dedicated biomedical scientists are making discoveries that translate into those new medical advances.

Biomedical science is broad, encompassing everything from social science to microbiology, biochemistry, epidemiology, to structural biology and bioinformatics to name just a few areas. And, it can involve basic fundamental biology, the use of AI and chemistry to clinical studies that evaluate new medicines in patients.

No matter the research focus, the goal is always the same, to advance human health. It may take a few months, a few years or for fundamental science, a few decades. Few people make the connection that biomedical science is medicine and that biomedical scientists are working today on the medicine of tomorrow. Our weekly 500-word newspaper columns and 2-minute radio shows and podcasts provide insights into a broad range of biomedical science topics.

Medical Discovery News is dedicated to explaining discoveries in biomedical research and their promise for the future of medicine.

Podcasts

Alternatively, you can copy and paste the following web address (URL) into iTunes as a new subscription:
https://www.medicaldiscoverynews.com/shows/audio/mdnews.rss

You can also search and subscribe to "Medical Discovery News" in the podcast section of iTunes.

The www.medicaldiscoverynews.com web site and Medical Discovery News radio program (Program) are made possible by The University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston (UTMB)as a community service and are intended to advance UTMB's mission of providing scholarly teaching, innovative scientific investigation, and state-of-the-art patient care in a learning environment to better the health of society and its commitment to the discovery of new innovative biomedical and health services knowledge leading to increasingly effective and accessible health care for the citizens of Texas.

All information provided on the web site and in the Program is for informational purposes only and is not intended for use as diagnosis or treatment of a health problem or as a substitute for consulting a licensed medical professional. Any information obtained by participating as a web site visitor or program listener is not intended to and should not be considered to constitute medical advice.

Thoughts and opinions expressed on the Program or on the website are those of the authors or guests and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of UTMB. The provision of links to other websites is not to be construed as written or implied sponsorship or endorsement of such websites by UTMB.

Please contact Dr. David Niesel or Dr. Norbert Herzog via email with any concerns, suggestions or comments.

All rights are reserved to information provided on the website or other information sources. No part of these programs can be reproduced stored in a retrieval system or transcribed in any form or by any means for personal or financial gained without the express written permission of Drs. Niesel and Dr. Herzog.